Feedback

The Live Wire

  • Jim Pickard | Why Blair did not want to topple Robert Mugabe

    • source icon
    • 19:11
  • Caron | Nick Clegg's plea for the people of Pakistan

    • source icon
    • 19:11
  • Kerry McCarthy | What’s going on

    • source icon
    • 19:06
  • Neil D | Well, somebody must like Blair

    • source icon
    • 18:57
  • James Forsyth | The biggest threat to the coalition

    • source icon
    • 18:56
  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

  • PoliticsHome | Only the latest five entries on the PhiWire are visible to non-subscribers

Top 5 Political Stories

  • 1
  • Office of Gordon and Sarah Brown set up
  • 2
  • Middle East peace talks begin
  • 3
  • Hague: I had to speak out
  • 4
  • 3,500 jobs to go at RBS
  • 5
  • Blair book fastest selling memoir ever

Other Top Stories

  • Pakistan cricketers out of England tour
  • Subscription Only
  • Ofgem investigates four energy firms
  • Subscription Only
  • IMF warns on UK finances
  • Subscription Only

New today

  • Oil rig explosion in Gulf of Mexico
  • Subscription Only
  • RMT: London tube strikes will go ahead
  • Subscription Only
  • Labour defends vote rules
  • Subscription Only
  • Scot alcohol minimum price 45p a unit
  • Subscription Only

New this morning

  • Attorney General requests Kelly files
  • Subscription Only
  • Adviser 'discussed phone hacking'
  • Subscription Only
  • D Miliband 'asked Blair not to back him'
  • Subscription Only
  • Darling: bonus supertax failed
  • Subscription Only
  • Hip replacements 'not quick enough'
  • Subscription Only
  • BP expects to 'plug leak for good'
  • Subscription Only
  • Community service 'holiday camp'
  • Subscription Only
  • Weight surgery 'postcode lottery'
  • Subscription Only
  • Gove hints failing primary schools will become academies
  • Subscription Only
  • British manufacturing slows
  • Subscription Only
  • Police complaint figures revealed
  • Subscription Only
  • Iran sentences two more to death by stoning
  • Subscription Only
  • NHS chiefs offered £130,000 to quit
  • Subscription Only
  • WikiLeaks rape investigation reopened
  • Subscription Only
  • Top universities 'should charge higher fees'
  • Subscription Only
  • BBC had 'massive bias to the left'
  • Subscription Only
  • House prices continue to fall
  • Subscription Only

MSM Catching up

  • Clegg issues Pakistan aid plea
  • Subscription Only
  • BBC staff back pensions strike
  • Subscription Only
Insider Research

Insider Research

Understanding the heart of Westminster

The Sleaze Meter

Labour MPs facing the most serious questions about expenses are thought to be Blears, Follett, Ussher, Vaz and Hoon. Tories Maude, Duncan, Gummer, Gove and Grayling are also singled out.

Hazel Blears is the MP who the panel most strongly feels needs to answer questions Hazel Blears is the MP who the panel most strongly feels needs to answer questions

After the revelations, the reckoning.  After the exposure of the parliamentary expenses racket, which of our leading politicians face the most serious questions about their avaricious behaviour?

We asked our experts and insiders on the PHI100 for their assessment.  From their collective judgement we can create what you might call a Sleaze Meter.  A score of 100 is the blackest rating.  0 is snow white.

Of the following list of MPs named by the Telegraph in connection with the expenses story which, if any, have stuck in your mind as having serious questions to answer?

Way out front, with a rating of 87, is Hazel Blears, the Housing Minister who is such a whizz at juggling her own portfolio that she claimed on three different properties in a single year.

Another high scorer is Barbara Follett, the Tourism Minister and wife of a multi-millionaire who landed the taxpayer with a big bill for her personal security.  She registers a 60.

Three leading Labour lights who exploited the expenses regime for 'second homes' come next on the Government side of the House.   They are Kitty Ussher, who had the taxpayer help do up her grotty flat in south London, on 48.  Keith Vaz, the man with a taste for silk cushions, on 43. Transport Secretary and property developer, Geoff Hoon scores 42.

The Tories In Most Trouble

Let's now turn to the Conservative side of the aisle after the revelations about their 'property flipping' and the rest of it in today's Daily Telegraph.

The Conservative with most serious questions to answer is Francis Maude, the Shadow Cabinet member who is in charge of Tory plans to cut Whitehall waste and yet is very adept at claiming taxpayers money to spend on himself.   He scores 46.

Alan 'Green Fingers' Duncan scores 46.  Another passionate gardener at the taxpayers' expense is former Cabinet Minister John Gummer.  He scores 33.

The flippers Michael Gove and Chris Grayling score 34 and 30 respectively.

Adams and Martin

Although members of Sinn Fein boycott the Commons, they seem to know their way around the Fees Office like it was the back of their hands. Gerry Adams scores 42.

The Speaker has serious questions to answer in the view of more than a third of the expert judges.  Michael Martin scores 39.

Probably In The Clear

Gordon Brown took the taxpayer for a cleaner and accidentally billed twice for the same plumbing bill.  But the vast majority of the panel think the Prime Minister doesn't have too much to answer for.  He gets a low reading on the Sleaze Meter of just 12.

Foreign Secretary David Miliband - whose claim for a pram was turned down - registers a low 13.

Margaret Beckett, another of the green-fingered MPs, can also breathe easier.  She gets a rating of only 11.

All Of Them

One left-leaning panellist believes 'all of them' have serious questions to answer.

Many panellists from across the political spectrum believe that the big scandal is the manipulation of the 'second home' allowance by some MPs in a way that has considerably enriched them.  Some panel members find it hard to distinguish that scam from fraud.

Leave a comment...

Irene Peters

Hazel Blears has committed fraud as far as this voter in concerned and should go. The whole second home expese is a fiasco and whilst I accept MP's 'have kept to the rules', I am certain the no one held a gun to their heads or forced them to claim to the max. I believe that the Govermenent, on behalf of the tax paperts, whould but blocks of flats which are currently un-sold and these should be used for MPs London accomodation. MPs would then pay for their own constutancy homes out of their own generous salary.   

John Best

What about Jack Straw, did he overclaim council tax in previous years?

Paul

Where's the audacious Margaret Moran?  Surely she's banged to rights?

Angry French John

Am I the only one who is a little suprised not to see Baroness Uddin here, or is her score so high she is off the scale.

angry eileen

This is abuse of us all. when are they going to stop taking our old peoples homes that they have worked all their lives for just because they need to go into a home What with the mps and the immigrants abusing the system its a wonder there is any money left. They can all ways put the fuel up and rob us some more

Andrew Roberts

I believe that Sir Fred (the shred) Goodwins pension was 'within the rules', but that didn't stop every MP who could get face time on the news channels from bleating about how wrong it was and that he should pay it back. So, MP's perhaps YOU should do the same!

Richard

Why aren't Jacqui Smith and Tony McNulty in the above list? Is it because their scores would be off the page?

Andrew Lefrench

Michael Martin has been the worst speaker in my memory.  How can one have any faith in a body that elects a person as its president who is prepared to sacrifice honest individual MPs in order to protect the corrupt system;  there must be processes to get rid of him quietly and unemotionally.

Jon Forest
  • 17:32 |
  • 11 May 2009
  • 0

How can "holiday home Moran" escape the list? In general, while fiddling is fiddling whatever the amount, the Tories figure a little too highly in this list, which seems to have been unfairly "balanced". The ingenuity of New (and old) Labour's troughers and junketers when it comes to playing the system appears to have left most Tories in the shade - unless future revelations prove the contrary.

Companygimp

Q - If all these MPs knew the system was 'rotten', why did they keep on sticking their snouts in the trough ? And why did - so far as I know - none of them openly declare it was 'rotten' prior to them being outed ? Sorry ? Sorry they were caught more like ?!

Nick Wakefield

I can't believe they are allowed to claim for food, this is not a work expense! I work for the NHS so i'm a civil servant like MPs, i have to eat at work otherwise i get cranky and can't do my job very well. I have to pay for my food out of my wages whether i'm working 2 miles or 200 miles from my house. Blears is my MP, i shall be asking her soem questions about this in one of my frequent letters to her telling her what a bad job she is doing.