Talk of a midterm ‘techlash’ is overblown, but voters need to feel the benefits of technology
Data centre in Milton Keynes (Amazing Aerial/Alamy)
3 min read
The Democrats have won in the midterms, striking deep into traditional Republican territory, with South Carolina, Maine and even Texas turning blue.
Commentators were swift in diagnosing the results as further evidence of a ‘techlash’ by communities angry with AI data centres and hostile towards the tech giants. There was a similar reaction in the stock markets, where investors rushed to sell their shares in technology firms in the days following the elections.
But while backlash against AI was certainly a feature in the midterms, it wasn’t the main issue that drove voters. Instead, NBC’s exit poll shows that cost of living was the biggest single issue at play. Many Americans feel worse off than they did two years ago, and that’s what encouraged them to vote out incumbent Republicans. So we should be cautious, lest we draw the wrong conclusions from this election.
Having said that, when AI was on the ballot specifically, it did quite badly. Out of 41 data centre-related measures being voted on across 10 states, the electorate backed restrictions or rejected pro-development measures in nearly all of them.
Only one jurisdiction – Harwood in North Dakota – appears to have voted in favour of data centres. But we shouldn’t run headlong into anti-tech sentiment which may not last. Instead, politicians should sketch out a better vision, one in which technology works in the interests of voters – especially the cost of living.
First, we should have a patriotic compact with technology companies. Their economic activity is good for Britain, whether in sectors like manufacturing and hardware or in software. It’s essential to our national strength and international importance. At the same time, if the government helps these firms to scale and develop, we want the taxpayer to share in the upside, with jobs, tax and capabilities staying here.
Second, data centres will have a place in this future. We all use them when we’re online, and they play an important role in both developing and running AI specifically. Britain will need data centres for our own security, and they go some way in giving us a place at the table – leverage – in the AI age.
Any vision for technology should recognise that we are in a geopolitical battle
Data centres won’t be suitable in every area, but where locals are in favour, they should bring benefits to the community: upgraded roads and schools, for instance, as well as the jobs that follow from their construction. They should lower the cost of electricity, perhaps by taking on some of the fixed costs of the grid, not increase it.
Third, AI companies should try to work out how they can deliver visible benefits for ordinary people in a short amount of time. I don’t mean the concentrated benefits that local areas should get from data centres, but broad-based benefits that all can enjoy. The most obvious path is medical and biological research, where even the comparatively limited AI technology of a few years ago is already having an impact. A cure for cancer will be a lot more popular than automating software engineering, as Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei has publicly acknowledged.
Finally, any vision for technology should recognise that we are in a geopolitical battle. Britain needs to stay at the frontier so we don’t get outcompeted by our foes. History is littered with examples of countries who were left at a total strategic disadvantage because a smaller opponent had better technology: from the Aztecs in the 16th century to the Chinese in the 19th. For 500 years, Britain has ridden a wave of innovation, staying ahead of the curve on everything from military to agricultural to engineering technology. Now is the time to do it again.
Danny Kruger is Reform UK MP for East Wiltshire