Skip to main content
Home
Open

  • Home
  • Green Box
  • Central Lobby
  • Calendar
  • The House
  • Must Reads
  • POLHOME PODCAST
  • Membership Service
    • Member directory
More ▼

News

  • Brexit
  • Videos
  • Communities
  • Culture
  • Defence
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Energy
  • Environment
  • Foreign Affairs
  • Health and Care
  • Home Affairs
  • Political Parties
  • Social Affairs
  • Transport

    Curb Home Office's immigration detention powers, MPs and peers demand

    Written by:
    • John Johnston
    Posted On: 
    7th February 2019

    The Home Office should be stripped of decision making powers in immigration detention cases, an influential group of MPs and peers has recommended.

    The report has called for an independent body to make the final decision on detention cases
    Credit: 
    PA Images

    In a hard-hitting new report, the Joint Committee on Human Rights have called for urgent reforms to the detention system in a bid to make them “fair, humane, decent and quick”.

    Labour MP Harriet Harman, who chairs the group, hit out at the absence of independent oversight in the process as she warned mistakes were “inevitable” if new safeguards were not implemented.

    EXCL Home Office 'risking another Windrush' as hundreds of carers face post-Brexit uncertainty

    Met Police chief calls on Home Office to show ‘greater leadership’

    Sajid Javid apologises after 'unacceptable' Home Office DNA demand saw migrants refused entry

    Mind responds to Joint Committee on Human Rights report on immigration detention

    “A civil servant – nameless, faceless and behind closed doors – just ticks a box to detain them,” she said.

    “The first that person will know about it is when someone bangs on their door in the early hours of the morning to bundle them into an immigration enforcement van and take them to a detention centre.”

    The group of MPs and peers say the treatment of the Windrush generation coupled with the £21m in compensation paid out by the department for wrongful detention proved that an independent arbiter should have the final say on cases.

    Ms Harman added: “If a person is suspected of a crime, they cannot be detained by the Government; they can be detained only by the police, who are independent of Government.

    “If the police want to continue to detain a person beyond 36 hours, they have to bring that person before a court, which is, of course, totally independent of Government.”

    The report also called on the Government to end the "mental torture" of indefinite detention by implementing a strict 28-day time limit except in exceptional cases.

    'LESS LIKE PRISONS'

    The UK is currently the only European country to allow detainees to be held indefinitely – something which the JCHR claims gives immigration officials a reduced incentive to work swiftly to resolve cases.

    In the third-quarter of 2018, 30% of all detainees were held for longer than 28 days, with 50 individuals being held for longer than a year.

    Among the reports other recommendations are better access for detainees to legal aid while they are being held, as well as calls to make detention centres “less like prisons” in a bid to reduce the anxiety and distress of those awaiting deportation decisions.

    Ms Harman added: “After the right to life, the right not to be unlawfully detained is one of the most important human rights. It should not be the case that a person has fewer protections from wrongful detention as an immigrant that they would if they had actually committed a crime.”

    “We should ensure that, in future, no one is detained unless the decision is taken independently. The Home Office should make its case, but someone independent must take the decision if a person is to be deprived of their liberty.”

    The Home Office have been approached for comment.

    Contributions from readers

    There are currently no comments on this article - be the first to comment by logging in or registering for a free account.

    Partner Content

    • Mind offers mental health support to MPs as Brexit takes its toll

      11th April 2019

      Paul Farmer, Chief Executive of mental health charity Mind, said MPs and their staff are working in a “uniquely pressurised environment” and are...

    • Immigration detention fails the fairness test, says Chair of the Bar

      22nd March 2019

      The indefinite detention of migrants by the Home Office is a stain on our justice system, says Chair of the Bar. 

    • Dame Carol Black: Solving the wellbeing puzzle

      16th February 2019

      Dame Carol Black advises how to create a wellbeing culture in the workplace in three new films produced by the British Safety Council.

    Related Press Releases

    • Mind responds to Joint Committee on Human Rights report on immigration detention

      7th February 2019

      Michael Henson-Webb, Head of Legal at Mind, said:

    • NFB: No deal and Immigration White Paper are damaging to construction

      19th December 2018

      Leaving the EU without a deal would be more catastrophic for the construction industry than the financial crisis of 2008 

    • We need a skills system that develops home-grown talent - CMI

      19th December 2018

      We need to accelerate the uptake of management apprenticeships and encourage all businesses to invest in the next generation of leaders, says Rob...

    • Liz Saville Roberts: Wales has a golden opportunity to succeed

      11th December 2019

    Comment

    • Lending £200 million in 2019, we must continue to scale up the responsible finance sector

      12th December 2019

    More News

    • Nicola Sturgeon says Boris Johnson must 'respect SNP's mandate' after stunning election success

      13th December 2019

      Nicola Sturgeon has called on Boris Johnson to agree to her demands for another Scottish referendum after the SNP made sweeping gains in the general election.

    • Boris Johnson says Conservative election win ‘gives him powerful new mandate’ on Brexit

      13th December 2019

      Boris Johnson has said the Conservatives' thumping election win has given him a "powerful new mandate" to deliver Brexit.

    • Stunning blow for Liberal Democrats as party leader Jo Swinson ousted by SNP

      13th December 2019

      The Liberal Democrats have been dealt a devastating blow after party leader Jo Swinson was ousted from her Commons seat by the SNP.

    • Jeremy Corbyn says he will stay on as Labour leader while party 'reflects' on crushing defeat

      13th December 2019

      Jeremy Corbyn has vowed to stay on as Labour leader during a "period of reflection" in the wake of the party's crushing election defeat.

    • DUP deputy leader Nigel Dodds loses his seat on seismic night for Northern Ireland politics

      13th December 2019

      DUP deputy leader Nigel Dodds has lost his Commons seat as the political map in Northern Ireland was redrawn.

    • Jeremy Corbyn allies blame Brexit as Labour heads for worst defeat since Second World War

      13th December 2019

      A fresh Labour civil war has erupted as the party heads for its worst general election result since the Second World War.

    • Lib Dem leader Jo Swinson on course to lose her seat, according to exit poll

      12th December 2019

      Lib Dem leader Jo Swinson is set to lose her seat, according to the exit poll.

    Editor's Choice

    • Jeremy Corbyn and Boris Johnson both offer to 'sort Brexit' in final election push

      11th December 2019
    • Technology experts say yes to e-voting, but let’s ensure it is secure first

      12th December 2019
    • Liz Saville Roberts: Wales has a golden opportunity to succeed

      11th December 2019

    Most read

    • Victims of IRA violence demand meeting with Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnell

      11th December 2019
    • Dominic Raab tops list of big-name MPs who could lose their seat on Thursday

      11th December 2019
    • Boris Johnson criticised over 'disgusting' single mother comments

      7th December 2019
    • Labour tax plans would hit 1.6m higher earners but returns 'highly uncertain', warns IFS

      20th November 2019
    • Final opinion polls put Conservatives in the lead - but hung Parliament still a possibility

      12th December 2019

    From the House magazine

    • Remembering Chris Moncrieff: The Lobby legend on half a century reporting on Westminster

      22nd November 2019

      One of Britain's most respected political journalists, Chris Moncrieff spent half a century reporting on Westminster. In 2016 he sat down with The...

    • Improving access and combating ‘fake news’: how the televising of Parliament has changed

      21st November 2019

      Today marks the 30th anniversary of the televising of the House of Commons. John Angeli, head of the Parliamentary Broadcasting Unit, reflects on...

    • Commons in Review: Historic firsts in the 2017 – 2019 Parliament

      5th November 2019

      In just two and a half years, the 2017 – 2019 Parliament made history with several firsts. From PMQs to parenting to periods, we remember some of...

    • Analysis: How did we get here?

      5th November 2019

      As Parliament dissolves, and the country prepares for a third general election in four years, Georgina Bailey looks back at the moments that have...

    Quick Links

    • News
    • The House Magazine
    • Green Box
    • Central Lobby
    • Calendar
    • Blogs
    • PoliticsHome Pro
    • Member Directory
    • Register
    • Sign Up

    About PoliticsHome

    • Contact Us
    • About PoliticsHome
    • Marketing Opportunities
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Cookies
    • RSS Feeds

    More From Dods

    • Total Politics
    • PublicTenders.net
    • Holyrood
    • Dods Information
    • Parliament Magazine
    • Dods Public Sector
    • Civil Service World
    • Dods Monitoring
    • Training Journal
    • Dods EU Monitoring
    • Westminster Briefing
    • Dods Shop
    • Dods Training
    • Electus
    • Public Affairs News
    • Dods
    • PublicTechnology.net

    About Dods

    • Dods
    • Investor Relations
    • Terms and Conditions

    Quantcast

      Search form

      • Log in
      • Register
      • Home
      • Green Box
      • Central Lobby
      • Calendar
        • PoliticsHome Memo
        • PoliticsHome Polls
      • The House
        • Brexit
        • Videos
        • Communities
        • Culture
        • Defence
        • Economy
        • Education
        • Energy
        • Environment
        • Foreign Affairs
        • Health and Care
        • Home Affairs
        • Political Parties
        • Social Affairs
        • Transport
      • Must Reads
      • POLHOME PODCAST
      • Membership Service
        • Member directory