Menu
Sat, 21 November 2026

Rosebank Is Becoming A Flash Point For Burnham

4 min read

Whether to approve drilling at the Rosebank oil field is threatening to trigger the first backbench rebellion of Andy Burnham's premiership.

"Rosebank is a flashpoint – it has all come to a head," remarked one senior Labour MP.

The government's decision last month to approve drilling at the Jackdaw site provoked little backlash from Labour MPs, despite protests from climate campaigners.

The Prime Minister described the "pragmatic" step as a way to raise funds to further help people with their energy bills, without undermining the UK's climate commitments. Most Labour MPs were comfortable with the rationale.

However, the prospect of Rosebank getting the green light is proving more contentious.

The Sunday Times reported earlier this month that up to 100 Labour MPs, including some Parliamentary Private Secretaries, were expected to sign a letter opposing it.

Labour MPs who accepted Jackdaw but oppose Rosebank say the two cases are different. They argue the latter would be a more serious breach of the UK's green agenda and risk costing Labour the progressive votes it needs to stay in power.

Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh admitted to The Times on Saturday that drilling at Rosebank would not reduce energy bills because the oil would be sold on global markets. Labour MPs opposed to the project have put forward the same argument.

The political risk of Labour creating the impression of not taking climate change seriously is alarming some of Burnham's backbenchers.

The Labour MP for Stourbridge, Cat Eccles, said approving Rosebank "could be a tipping point" for Burnham's popularity with progressives, who she believes "were probably able to swallow Jackdaw, and they won’t swallow Rosebank". "My constituency has a big block of Green voters who have lobbied me hard on this," she told PoliticsHome.

Labour donor and climate campaigner Dale Vince also believes Labour risked losing momentum “in gaining voters from the left and the progressive side."

“The crowning glory so far of Burnham as Prime Minister has been in the return of voters from that side. It's been incredible, and it would be a gift to the Greens to undermine that," Vince told PoliticsHome.

He added that while Jackdaw was “survivable” for Labour, Rosebank would have a “different kind of impact”.

A new Survation poll of 2,011 people, commissioned by Vince's Green Britain Foundation and published on Saturday, found that more than half of people support drilling at Rosebank (52 per cent), while 19 per cent oppose it. 

However, Vince stressed that of respondents who would consider voting for Zack Polanski's Green Party at the next election, 32 per cent said approving Rosebank would make them less likely to vote Labour, and 19 per cent more likely.

My constituency has a big block of Green voters who have lobbied me hard on this

The Greens' declining popularity and internal problems triggered by their recent "Zionism is racism" motion are believed to have created a feeling in No 10 that Labour is less vulnerable to Polanski's attacks than it was months ago. A YouGov poll this week put the Greens on 9 per cent, its lowest vote share since June 2025.

As one Labour backbencher put it: “It’s clear that Burnham has moved to the right somewhat as the threat from the Greens has diminished and equally as the right-wing parties [Conservatives and Reform UK] are still slugging it out."

But Rosebank's opponents warn that approving the project could give Polanski an unnecessary boost at a difficult time for the self-styled eco-populist.

Rob Ford, politics professor at the University of Manchester, agreed that the Greens were weaker now than they were earlier in Polanski's leadership, when the party secured an historic by-election victory over Labour in Gorton and Denton.

However, he added: "He [Burnham] shouldn’t get too cocky, though. Things can shift again. They have done so several times in recent years."

Labour MPs who support Rosebank say it would create jobs, generate tax revenue, and boost the UK's energy security amid international instability.

"It's about net zero vs the cost of living," said one senior Labour MP.

"People have been squeezed for years now, and if it [net zero] is piling on more costs, the government runs the risk of losing public support."

There is concern among pro-Rosebank Labour MPs that Burnham hasn't done enough to lay the groundwork for approving the oilfield.

One senior Labour MP told PoliticsHome that Burnham had framed the argument for welfare reform "extremely well" ahead of Alan Milburn's NEETs review, but had failed to do the same on energy security.

The Rosebank decision is emerging as perhaps the first major test of Burnham's authority since entering Downing Street in July. That's because, for many Labour MPs, it raises a much bigger question about the government's direction of travel.

“It’s about the wider agenda: are we walking away from net zero or not," said one Labour MP.

Additional reporting by Adam Payne