Union Boss Warns Milburn's NEET Proposals Would Exacerbate Teacher Pressures
Matt Wrack has criticised the Milburn Review (NASUWT)
3 min read
The head of a teaching union has warned that Alan Milburn's proposal to impose new accountability measures on schools to tackle youth unemployment would put pressure on already stretched teachers and resources.
Writing for The House this weekend, general secretary of NASUWT Matt Wrack said schools in disadvantaged areas in particular would be "unfairly penalised".
"We reject any approach based on welfare cuts or the blaming of schools and teachers," he wrote.
Milburn’s highly anticipated report on nearly one million young people in the UK not in education, employment or training (NEET), published Tuesday, outlined “a 10-year project” to address what the former health secretary described as the "moral crisis" of youth unemployment.
The review, which Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden welcomed as a "radical blueprint", recommended welfare reform as well as more state support for young people.
Milburn also suggested changes to the education system, proposing that schools be judged by the inspectorate Ofsted on a "new ready-for-work standard" to ensure young people leave school in a better position to secure employment.
However, Wrack is highly critical of this idea, writing that "schools do exactly this already" and questioning how an Ofsted inspector could determine whether a teenager is ready for work.
The union leader said these are not "new priorities that somehow teachers and school leaders did not think about until a former health secretary last in government 20 years ago pointed it out to them".
Wrack pointed to the risks for schools, warning that they "risk being judged on outcomes they do not control with implications for budgets already stripped bare."
"With schools facing severe staff recruitment and retention challenges, rising levels of pupil need, growing mental health concerns and an increasingly stretched special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) system, the last thing teachers need is yet another accountability framework," he wrote.
Wrack said that a young person's post-school prospects are "shaped primarily by the local economy, the availability of local jobs, apprenticeships and transport links", which is "entirely outside the control of schools and of teachers; a point Milburn seems to miss".
With staffing and teacher recruitment an ongoing concern among education leaders, Wrack warned: "Schools may find themselves devoting scarce staff time and resources to meeting new measures linked to factors outside their control. There is a real danger that schools serving disadvantaged communities will be unfairly penalised because of this."
The Labour government has already accepted several of Milburn's recommendations, including creating a new "Youth Opportunities Unit". However, further details on its next steps are not expected until a white paper in the new year.
A DfE spokesperson told PoliticsHome: “Government is yet to respond to the review and anything we consider will recognise the pressures schools are facing, and will make sure accountability remains fair, proportionate and focused on helping every school get better."