It's time to change the outdated rules employees face when leaving the Civil Service
5 min read
The Civil Service’s post-employment rules are stuck in the 1970s. Designed for a very different world of work, the system risks deterring the skilled people government really needs.
Private sector executives might have enforced periods of gardening leave or be made to sign non-competes when they leave a job. The Civil Service has similar rules to protect the integrity of government, known as the Business Appointments Rules. Their name alone conjures the world in which they were created: a senior figure leaving a lifetime in public service with a generous pension to join the board of a large company. That may have reflected common career patterns in the Civil Service of the 70s and 80s. But the Rules - owned by the government - have remained broadly the same since, while the way people move into, through and out of the Civil Service has changed fundamentally.
Today’s Civil Service is not a closed career for life. People are recruited for specialist expertise, move between government and other sectors, and leave at different stages of their careers. A system designed around a retirement model now applies to a younger, more varied and mobile workforce.
An outdated exit system risks alienating the very people government wants to recruit. Recent plans for Civil Service reform rely heavily on attracting mid-career talent from industry, particularly in tech, data science, commercial delivery, and fast-moving global markets like AI. But they are put off from taking public roles due to fear and uncertainty about how the Rules might constrain their future career moves.
The independent Civil Service Commission, which I chair, oversees external recruitment into the Civil Service. Last year, it was also asked to advise the most senior civil servants, special advisers and diplomats under the Business Appointment Rules. That gives us a view of both ends of the system: how government attracts people with valuable skills and experience, and what happens when they leave. We have been examining how exits are managed and where the present arrangements create unnecessary obstacles without strengthening public confidence.
The Rules apply for two years after someone leaves public office. During that period, civil servants must seek advice before taking up any new paid or unpaid role. The intention is legitimate: to prevent privileged access, inside knowledge or decisions made in office from being used improperly after departure. The question is whether applying the same lengthy process so widely is the best way to protect against those risks.
Leavers told us they were unclear about the process, and found it slow and unresponsive. Some faced significant financial hardship while waiting for BARs advice so they could begin a new job. It is not unheard of for applications to take more than 6 months to resolve, leaving individuals in professional and financial limbo.
The Rules do not distinguish sharply enough between a high-risk application - where an official has been directly involved in a contract or bid - and a low-risk request such as taking up an unpaid role chairing a parish council audit committee. Although government has introduced practical measures to categorise and speed up lower risk cases, the Rules treat all such cases as though they warrant the same level of scrutiny.
An outdated exit system risks alienating the very people government wants to recruit
The two-year timeframe assumes that knowledge acquired in government may remain commercially or politically sensitive long after an official leaves. On some occasions it will. But policy, markets and technology all move faster than they did in the 1970s. The system should assess the continuing sensitivity of the information and the individual’s involvement, rather than rely so heavily on the blanket two year window. For some, that may be longer than their actual Civil Service posting.
Modernisation must not mean relaxing scrutiny where a move creates a real risk to government integrity, for example, where someone seeks work connected to a contract, commercial decision or policy for which they recently had direct responsibility. A more proportionate system would free time and expertise for those cases.
However, the challenge begins long before someone leaves. Departments could do a lot more at the onboarding stage so people enter government aware of the Rules they are signing up for. And when people join government for a specific project or a fixed period, we think their exit plan should be agreed up front. A more risk-based system with proportionate safeguards would protect integrity without turning public service into a professional cul-de-sac.
Our proposals - published today - are practical, cost-neutral and don’t require legislation. They will make the process faster and more predictable without weakening the safeguards around genuinely sensitive moves. They include a major push with departments to raise awareness and understanding of the Rules from day one. We also want to use transparency to maximum effect, including searchable databases, compliance check-ins for high-risk appointments, and clearer expectations for recruiting employers.
We all want a state that can get things done, and that requires a Civil Service with the skills to do it. The Business Appointment Rules should protect integrity in today’s world, without imposing avoidable delay on routine career moves or deterring talented people from entering government in the first place.
Baroness Gisela Stuart is a crossbench peer and First Civil Service Commissioner