We have a moral duty to reform welfare
4 min read
Back in 2008, my family was in crisis. We'd had to leave our home in Northern Ireland, and I’d had to leave my job.
In the middle of an economic downturn, I found myself unemployed, dealing with bereavement and responsible for my wife and three-year-old child.
In six months of unemployment, I learnt two things. Firstly, that the support I received at the job centre was a perfunctory exchange to justify a (small) payment, not a meaningful effort to return me to the world of work. Secondly, the biggest toll that we paid was psychological – the blow to a sense of self-worth, dignity and purpose.
If that was how a 30-year-old with a Master's degree and a decade of work felt after six months, think of young people who spend years neither earning nor learning.
In the build-up to the publication of the Milburn review today, almost everyone has agreed that we need to act. He said at the review launch that this is a "moral crisis" – but I would say that there are two moral causes driving this debate.
One camp sees an issue of fairness. Why can someone on benefits end up with more at the end of the week than a minimum wage worker after six days of hard graft?
The other camp sees a question about the humanity of welfare reform. The support the welfare system offers is not generous (the UK is only just above the OECD average on social spending). Why should we balance the budget on the backs of the vulnerable?
Perhaps this is a moment, though, when the moral arguments can be balanced.
We are beginning to see how badly the system is skewed away from meaningful support. As Alan Milburn found in the interim review, for every £25 spent on benefits, only £1 goes on NEET. We’re spending more on an aging population, but we need to invest in young people.
The welfare system has become a sticking plaster over gaping holes in life chances: the regional economies that have lagged, the education systems which have not always met the real needs of today’s young people, the apprenticeships that are harder than ever to get.
We do need reform. And we need costs to come down. But reform and cost-cutting are not the same. The Milburn review offers a blueprint for what we want before we build.
There are some who simply can’t work, and we have a duty to them. But there are many who might work with better support, and we owe them a duty too
The very idea of the welfare state, popularised by former Archbishop of Canterbury William Temple, assumes that a state draws its legitimacy from securing its citizens' welfare. The original power of the idea wasn’t that there would be a huge Department for Work and Pensions, but that the welfare of the people was the whole purpose of the state.
But welfare is much more than material security: it is agency and control, growth and learning, creativity and care, and the chance to meet our duties to family, community and nation. For me, people realise these things most easily through work.
There are some who simply can’t work, and we have a duty to them. But there are many who might work with better support, and we owe them a duty too. Eighty-four per cent of NEETs say they want work or training – yet only 1 in 5 receive any support from the local job centre.
That needs to change. As Milburn says: “The system I propose will spend less on compensating for economic inactivity, more on creating routes out of it; less on the consequences of failure, and more on avoiding it."
Reform will not be painless. Some people will lose cash support or face new expectations to look for work. The emails will come into our inboxes: "My life will become more difficult because of these reforms." We must be able to answer, remembering that many people are already losing within the system we have.
A few years after my own crisis I became the CEO of a homelessness charity. We offered employability to men and women who had never been in work despite being well into their mid-life. Their steps towards the world of work – as small as learning how to use a bus to get to the town centre – made a huge difference to their well-being.
We should seize the opportunity to build a system that is more human, not just cheaper.
David Smith is the Labour MP for North Northumberland