Menu
Thu, 19 November 2026
THEHOUSE

Poverty prevention is the key to fixing the twin crises of rough sleeping and NEETs

Image by: Gerard Ferry / Alamy

3 min read

All of the emergency efforts in the world won't cure poverty

The Chancellor of the Exchequer quietly dropped a neat bit of prevention thinking into his recent budget. At the next spending review, the government will introduce a new category of spending, ‘PDEL’ – or ‘Preventative Departmental Expenditure Limits’ – meaning that money will be ring-fenced to be spent only on prevention, rather than being sucked away to deal with the next emergency.

Take rough sleeping, or the million young NEETs decried by Alan Milburn. Fixing both crises – as Andy Burnham has promised to do – needs us to work in the emergency but work even harder to stop people falling into that emergency. Faced with the enormous welfare bill, it seems government has finally surrendered to the argument that we must learn to ‘turn the tap off’ in these situations, rather than just mopping up the mess.

John Healey’s announcement was a change that went mostly under the radar but has seismic potential. Perhaps the ‘inheritance of poverty’, which I have stressed for so long as the biggest predictor of living in poverty, will at last be addressed. But will it be? Or will it be just the window dressing that the civil service and governments encourage, rather than the big change we desperately need?

There are distinct chances that, despite the good intentions, Andy Burnham’s government could again slip into growing the big emergency behemothic bubble that is increasingly unaffordable. The Treasury has always found the whole concept of prevention difficult. How can you measure it? How can you dig out data to back up claims of prevention? The Treasury loves to and needs to show measurements and achievements.

Wouldn’t it be sensible for the government to actually get behind my bill and make it their own?

But the pursuit of measuring the general decline in society due to poverty increases, and using social security as a warehousing of people, is a madness. And not sustainable. It becomes an unbearable bastille that you commit people to, and at the same time it is not a good use of public money, when you should be getting people back into supporting themselves and not leaving them languishing in a limbo of inactivity.

And so today I am persisting in introducing my new Private Members’ Bill, calling for a commissioner for poverty prevention. It outlines the need for a commissioner to be put in charge of preventing poverty and not carrying on the ridiculous situation in government of about eight departments having their fingers in the poverty pie.

Wouldn’t it be sensible for the government to actually get behind my bill and make it their own? Turn it slightly, change it, but keep its force and thrust, and by that, make it work for them. But of course, as I have been often told, if you want something to work with the government then you have to make it look as though it’s their idea. Grudgingly I can go with that, but surely Big Issue could get some kudos for its clarity of thinking: that you cannot cure poverty by all of the emergency efforts in the world.

Good news is coming from government, let’s not knock it. But let’s keep an eye on what actually happens to this promise of prevention. Giving the poor a little bit more has dominated the thinking of Parliament and government for so long that it will be a big day when they get around to preventing more and stopping these emergencies occurring in the first instance.

Lord Bird is a crossbench peer and founder of the Big Issue