Menu
Mon, 16 November 2026
THEHOUSE

"Compelling": Tom Tugendhat reviews 'Courage Can Save Us'

US Senator Mark Kelly | Image: Bill Ingalls / NASA / Alamy Live News

3 min read

A profile of 10 Americans who put duty ahead of their political careers, Rye Barcott's book reveals how moral courage can strengthen democracy

An argument in Parliament is not a firefight in Helmand. Nobody who has experienced the latter would confuse the two. Yet the question at the heart of Rye Barcott’s Courage Can Save Us belongs in both places: what are you prepared to risk for something beyond yourself?

Barcott begins not in Washington, but with his father’s face: a scar from Vietnam, a smoke grenade that stopped a bullet, and a medal citation his father had annotated with blunt corrections. The lesson is immediate. Courage is more complicated than the stories we tell about it.

A former US Marine and co-founder of the cross-party organisation With Honor, which encourages principled veterans into public office to help combat political polarisation, Barcott profiles 10 American politicians: five Democrats, five Republicans, nine military veterans and one former FBI agent who served in Iraq. They have different convictions and uneven records. What unites them is a willingness, at consequential moments, to put duty ahead of political convenience.

Some of the book’s strongest passages concern Afghanistan. Seth Moulton, a Democrat and former marine, challenged the Biden administration over its failure to evacuate Afghan allies quickly enough. With Republican veteran Peter Meijer, he travelled to Kabul as the withdrawal collapsed into chaos. Their visit attracted fierce criticism. That matters, too: moral courage and good judgement are not necessarily the same thing. Barcott asks us to look beyond the easy accusation of disloyalty and consider what obligation meant to men who had served alongside those being left behind.

We need not surrender our convictions to recognise a shared interest

Then there is Don Bacon, a Republican who refused to indulge his party’s equivocation over Russia’s aggression in Ukraine. He understood both the strategic stakes and the political price of saying so. His story is less about one spectacular stand than the cumulative toll of taking positions that powerful people would prefer you kept to yourself.

This is not disinterested reportage. With Honor supported these politicians, and Barcott knows and admires them. Occasionally, one wants him to press a little harder. But he does not pretend they are saints, and his distinction between bravery in the moment and courage exercised through conscience is persuasive.

Nor is military service a qualification for being right. I have known good soldiers who were wrong and civilians of extraordinary resolve. Likewise, working across parties is not an end in itself. Sometimes principle demands opposition. The real test is whether we can distinguish conviction from habit and patriotism from loyalty to a political tribe.

Courage can save us coverAl Carns and I sit on opposite sides of the Commons Chamber. We both served in Afghanistan, and we disagree on plenty. But we have worked together to argue for greater opportunities for young people to serve their country, in uniform and beyond it. We need not surrender our convictions to recognise a shared interest.

Near the end, Barcott tells his dying mentor David Gergen that nearly 50 With Honor veterans now serve in Congress. Gergen replies with a single word: “Good.” 

It is a quiet moment in a book about courage, and perhaps its most telling. The point is not simply to praise brave people, but to make public service worthy of them.

Tom Tugendhat is Conservative MP for Tonbridge and shadow foreign secretary

Courage Can Save Us: Ten Extraordinary Americans and the Fight for Our Future
By: Rye Barcott
Publisher: Head of Zeus

Categories

Books & culture