Menu
Wed, 18 November 2026
THEHOUSE

"Much-needed perspective": Andy MacNae reviews 'Tenzing'

'Tenzing' | Image courtesy of AppleTV

4 min read

With its stunning cinematography and attention to detail, this excellent film casts fresh light on the story of the first men to reach the summit of Everest

The new film Tenzing brings a much-needed perspective on the first ascent of Everest/Chomolungma. As a climber in the 80s I had the privilege of meeting most of the first ascent team. I even got to share a few beers with Edmund Hillary when he came for one of his rare UK visits. Apart from Hillary (a New Zealander), these were the elder statesmen of British mountaineering, telling and retelling the story at dinners, events and on film.

But we never heard from Tenzing Norgay, his story always told by others. That is not to say Tenzing’s role was ever downplayed but we always got the legend and never the man. And this has been generally the case in film and book ever since 1953. Tenzing did, however, publish his autobiography in 1977 and I presume much of the film’s back story is based on this.

Tenzing & Hillary
Tom Hiddleston as Edmund Hillary and Genden Phuntsok as Tenzing Norgay
Image courtesy of AppleTV

By centring on Tenzing and portraying his life before Everest, this film brings further balance. It reminds us what a unique character he was. An outsider, a non-Sherpa, for whom even getting that first job as a lowly porter was an achievement, to full climbing member of the 1952 and 1953 expeditions – his sheer ability and weight of experience making any other choice impossible.

There are of course holes I could pick (come on guys put your sunglasses on!)

Genden Phuntsok’s performance as Tenzing brings this remarkable man to life. Thinley Lhamo, playing his wife Dawa, is the emotional core. On location filming and attention to detail with equipment and technique provides the authenticity. The mountain shots are often stunning and the climbing scenes are as accurate as we could reasonably expect. It is clear that the filmmakers cared about getting this right.

There are, of course, holes I could pick (come on guys put your sunglasses on) and some historical licence (sorry, but Tenzing never met George Mallory) but it is all forgivable and generally helps the story along.

Dawa and Tenzing
Thinley Lhamo as Dawa and Tenzin Dalha plays the younger Tenzing
Image courtesy of AppleTV

What of the other expedition members? Most are pretty generic “chaps”, although Willem Dafoe did feel right as Colonel John Hunt. I remember him as a fierce and distant character, very much the military man.

Tom Hiddleston as Hillary can’t quite capture the physical presence or taciturn nature of this humble man. But he does present Hillary as the outsider he was and the film presents this as the basis of the relationship between Hillary and Tenzing. This rings true, but they were also simply the best climbers at altitude and were always destined for the main summit bid.

I liked the fact that despite the film’s focus on Tenzing, it did not try and downplay Hillary’s role, particularly in leading the final steep, rocky section. This last obstacle to the summit has ever since been known as the Hillary Step. 

Tenzing posterAnd the two were shown reaching the summit together. In reality we don’t know if this happened as both men would never be drawn on those final steps, well aware of the press obsession with ‘first’. And so they remain inseparable in a way that, say, Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin never were allowed to be. This speaks again to the great respect that they had for one another, and this evolved into a lifelong friendship.

And this really is a film about relationships – Hunt and his team, Tenzing and Dawa, Tenzing and Hillary – but most of all it is about Tenzing and Chomolungma. A 20-year commitment, with good times and bad, that ultimately led to fulfilment. This excellent film tells their story well.

Andy MacNae is Labour MP for Rossendale & Darwen

Tenzing
Directed by: Jennifer Peedom
Broadcaster: AppleTV

Categories

Books & culture