Menu
Tue, 17 November 2026
THEHOUSE

Struggling US voters have made clear they want real change, centre-left parties will fail if they offer more of the same

(Sipa US/Alamy)

4 min read

It’s often said the US is a barometer of Britain’s political weather.

After the drubbing Donald Trump’s Republicans took in the midterms, plenty will be wondering whether Nigel Farage is in for a soaking. I’d be wary: the obvious difference is that Trump has had to answer for the cost of living. At the next election it will be a Labour government answering for the mounting heap of bills households face.

What Britain does share with the US, and with much of Europe, is an electorate impatient with the choices the established parties have offered it. In October, AP–NORC found that 84 per cent of American voters counted the cost of living among their most important issues, 69 per cent said healthcare and 64 per cent the war with Iran. Eight in 10 wanted substantial change or a complete upheaval in how their country was run. Just four in 10 had a favourable view of the Democratic Party. It’s a leap to read those figures as an endorsement of what centrist Democrats (known now as ‘Corporate Dems’) had to offer.

Michigan gives us a better idea. Before Abdul El-Sayed could take on the Republicans, he had to win an argument inside his own party. Backed by the United Auto Workers, he ran on universal healthcare, challenged corporate money and spoke out over Gaza. One of his defeated Democratic rivals went on to endorse his Republican opponent. Michigan elected him anyway.

Andy Burnham knows about winning an argument inside his own party. A former New Labour Cabinet minister, he came to power promising to end 40 years of neoliberalism. He had read the room rather better than his former fellow centrists. Under his predecessor, we talked tough on asylum, proscribed Palestine Action and proposed digital ID and curbs on jury trials. Meanwhile, the economic settlement that had left millions struggling, survived largely intact. We gave Labour voters multiple reasons to walk away – with little evidence Farage’s supporters were coming towards us.

Burnham has since dropped the digital ID scheme and the extension of judge-only trials. The harder question is whether he can bring the same conviction to economic policy. The vision is there – but delivery is proving elusive. Thames Water, the poster-child of neoliberal economic failure, has yet to be put out of its misery and into special administration as a prelude to public ownership. His first Budget “tinkers with small things around the edges” according to 60 per cent of those polled post-Budget by More in Common. Boston Consulting Group, one of the world’s biggest management consultancies, has been brought in to help shape the 10-year plan to end neoliberalism: I’m not alone in marvelling at the irony. Can the master’s tools dismantle the master’s house? We shall soon see.

What Britain shares with the US, and with much of Europe, is an electorate impatient with the choices the established parties have offered it

A family in Norwich opening its energy bill after yet another international price shock has to get through this winter. Ministers can reasonably explain that Britain has little say over the world price of gas. But that family can reasonably ask why that leaves them carrying the risk?

I’ll shortly be hosting the economist Isabella Weber in Parliament to discuss her book Anti-Fascist Economics. During Germany’s energy crisis, Weber helped devise a scheme to cap the price of a basic allowance of gas, so households could plan for winter. In 2022, I introduced a Private Members’ Bill proposing a free basic energy allowance for every household here. Both proposals start from the same principle: governments have a choice about who bears the cost of a shock. If the best answer Labour can give voters is that, ‘global prices have risen’, rest assured Farage will be along to tell them who to blame.

That brings us back to the US. The Democrats have two years to find a programme and a presidential candidate their progressive and corporate wings can rally around. Labour already has the power to show what a change of direction can mean. Both parties of the centre left have been afforded something rare in politics: a second chance. There won’t be a third. 

Clive Lewis is Labour MP for Norwich South