The law on careless and dangerous driving is inadequate
Wayne David MP will call on the Government to have an additional public consultation on the legal division between careless and dangerous driving.
Some time ago I was approached by a constituent whose son had been killed in a car accident. The constituent explained to me how his son had died, along with two other young men, after a car in which they had been passengers crashed into a roadside telegraph post.
My constituent and the families of the other young men were appalled by the fact that the driver of the car, in their view, had been given an extremely lenient sentence, which did not reflect the gravity of the crime he had committed. In the trial that followed the accident, the defendant had been found guilty of causing death by careless driving, after a charge against him of causing death by dangerous driving had been dismissed by the judge.
The custodial sentence given to the defendant was 10 months, after he had pleaded guilty to causing death by careless driving.
This case brought home to me the deficiencies in the law and the inadequacies in the sentencing guidelines relating to driving offences. In particular, I believe that the division between ‘careless driving’ and ‘dangerous driving’ is unhelpful and inappropriate. Like many others who have considered this issue, I have come to the conclusion that the law needs to be changed to bring an end to the unfortunate division which, all too often, encourages prosecutors and judges to err on the side of caution in pursuit of a lesser charge.
The Ministry of Justice has recently concluded a consultation on ‘Driving offences and penalties relating to causing death or serious injury’. Unfortunately, the Government did not consult on the division between careless driving and dangerous driving, although they acknowledged that this was an issue of debate.
In my adjournment debate I will be calling on the Government to have an additional public consultation on the legal division between careless and dangerous driving, so that consideration might be given to a change in the law.
Wayne David is the Labour MP for Caerphilly
Get the inside track on what MPs and Peers are talking about. Sign up to The House's morning email for the latest insight and reaction from Parliamentarians, policy-makers and organisations.